0:00
/
0:00

Why I Stopped Believing God Always Heals

Faith is a journey of learning, believing, and growing. Sometimes you abandon certain beliefs you picked up along the way.

HeinzSight is where I explore life, work, and faith—hoping to inspire and stir your own thoughts along the way.

Follow me on Instagram


For years, my wife and I were part of a movement that taught that every sickness should be healed. We were immersed in a culture of declarations, special prayers, and spiritual diagnostics—searching for hidden sin that might be blocking our healing. The message was clear: if you weren’t healed, you were doing something wrong.

But over time, that belief began to unravel. We saw faithful people suffer. We prayed fervently, declared boldly, and searched our hearts deeply—yet healing didn’t always come. The tension between our theology and reality became too great to ignore.

One verse often used to support the idea that God always heals is 1 Peter 2:24:

“He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree, that we might die to sin and live to righteousness. By his wounds you have been healed.

At first glance, it seems to promise physical healing. But is that what Peter meant?

Photo by Valentin Angel Fernandez on Pexels

Digging Into the Text

The Greek word translated “healed” (iaomai) can refer to physical healing, but it also carries the meaning of spiritual restoration. In this passage, Peter isn’t talking about physical ailments—he’s talking about sin. The verse begins with Christ bearing our sins in His body on the cross, and ends with the result: we die to sin and live to righteousness.

This isn’t about curing every disease. It’s about the deeper healing—freedom from the power and penalty of sin.

The Bigger Picture

Zooming out, the context of 1 Peter 2 is rich with themes of suffering, submission, and sanctification. Verse 16 says,

“Live as people who are free, not using your freedom as a cover-up for evil, but living as servants of God.”

Peter is writing to believers who are suffering unjustly. He’s encouraging them to endure, just as Christ did. The healing he speaks of is not a promise of physical ease, but of spiritual transformation. It’s about living holy lives, obeying the authorities God has placed over us, and walking in freedom—not from sickness, but from sin.

A Pastoral Reflection

I understand the longing for healing. When pain persists, we search for answers. We want the right prayer, the right person, the right formula. But sometimes, healing doesn’t come. And that doesn’t mean God has failed us.

God’s ways are mysterious. He is sovereign, and He is good. The greater work He offers is spiritual healing—freedom from the sin that separates us from Him. That healing is eternal. It’s the kind that transforms our hearts, renews our minds, and sets us on a path of righteousness.

So when we read, “By his wounds you have been healed,” let’s not reduce it to a guarantee of physical wellness. Let’s receive it as a profound truth: Jesus bore our sins so we could be free. Free to live holy lives. Free to obey. Free to be servants of God.

That’s the healing we all need most.


Related Posts:


Thanks for reading HeinzSight with Chris Heinz! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Note: The views expressed here are my own.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?